WHERE DID WHITEHEAD’S LATER IDEAS COME FROM?
After he moved from England to America, Whitehead’s philosophical thought underwent a radical shift away from the work he and Bertrand Russell had been pursuing in their groundbreaking “Principia Mathematica” toward what became his new “Process and Reality” perspective, expressed in his 1941 book by that name. The puzzle is that this shift finds no roots or prior examination in any of his earlier writings. On page xii of his preface to “Process and Reality,” Whitehead suggests that he is an American thinker, along with Wm. James and John Dewey, as well as Henri Bergson, but neither here nor anywhere else does he provide any specifics as to what aspects of these thinkers he had in mind. They all, especially Bergson, offer a fresh approach to traditional questions about the nature of reality, but Whitehead never offers any specifics as to what it might have been that attracted him to their thought.
Bergson, of course, offered a fresh way to think about reality as a dynamic process, the “elan vital,” that drives reality and thus its history “forward” toward some sort of final fulfillment of its reality. Both James and Dewey stressed the “action” or “process” character of reality and human experience, but neither sought to construct an entire metaphysical system from it. In James’ account of Zeno’s paradoxes about time, Whitehead agrees with James that time is continuous and not analytically divisible (cf. p. 68). However, aside from such brief references to James and Dewey, Whitehead never actually tries to explain his own approach to “process thought” in relation to these earlier American thinkers. Nor does he ever offer anything like a detailed account of how his own thought directly draws upon that of these Pragmatist thinkers.
Perhaps Whitehead simply assumed that readers of his book would clearly see the connections between his fresh approach and those of his forerunners. However, it is far from clear how any of these “forerunners” can be understood as real sources for his new philosophy of “Process,” as spelled out in such great and specific detail in “Process and Reality.” Of course, in a broad sense, it can be claimed that Whitehead had been influenced in a general way by the spirit of his newly found country, America. Also, perhaps he was glad to be free of the more traditional confines of British philosophical thought as he knew it at Cambridge. There is something of a free-wheeling tone and spirit to “Process and Reality” that belies the British background of Whitehead’s earlier philosophical training and interests.
I am reminded of the comment attributed to Whitehead, made to Bertrand Russell while they were working on their “Principia Mathematica” together. Whitehead is said to have said to Russell: “You know, Bertie, you are simple-minded while I am muddle-headed.” Russell was, to be sure,
While Russell was primarily an Empiricist and Logician, Whitehead was more metaphysically inclined. In any case, Whitehead has become a widely influential philosopher in his own right, equal in stature and influence to Russell himself. “Process and Reality” has become a genuine classic in the history of modern philosophy, partly because it seems to align with the more “open spirit” of contemporary times as well as with contemporary scientific theorizing.
Leave a Reply